Kids will be kids, until they have to lead an army into battle. Then they’re just immature adults.
An alien race called the Formics has attacked Earth, and as you could presume, the citizens of that said planet aren’t too happy. So, that’s when they decide to set-up a military school in which they will enlist pre-teens to learn the tricks of the trade, be tested, be challenged and be the best that they can truly be, so that one day, they too can get a chance to fight in the war. The reason why a school like this even exists is because the government feels as if they get kids, whose minds aren’t as developed or as complex yet, then there will be no problems whatsoever with the enlisting or training-process. However, that’s where a boy named Ender Wiggins (Asa Butterfield), comes in a screws everything up. Not only does Ender have something special within him that lead Colonel Graff (Harrison Ford) can see, but also has a bit of an open-mind to any situation he finds himself in. Sure, that impresses a lot of the instructors, but doesn’t make him the coolest kid on the playground. But, it’s fine because Ender doesn’t care, all he cares about is putting his skills to the test and see if he can take out the Formic threat once and for all. Like with most war-fare though, there do come some prices one must pay.
So yeah, a lot has been said about this movie, but then again, it’s not necessarily about the movie itself. Nope, it’s more about how author Orson Scott Card himself was a bit of a loony and took it upon himself to let everybody know that he’s homophobic. Personally, whatever the guy wants to say or do, is fine by me. Sure, he may be a bit shallow and narrow-minded, but he’s a human, he’s entitled to his opinion and quite frankly, he didn’t make this movie, so why should I care? What I should care about here is the actual movie I have on hand here, and if it actually does its job in being some sort of meeting between Harry Potter and Star Wars, as I heard it being compared as.
It doesn’t meet those standards, but it’s not a total bomb. Here’s why:
For the most part, this flick is kind of weird. Director Gavin Hood clearly knows that he’s working with some heavy-duty source-material here that may not entirely be for kids, nor may it not entirely be for the adults either. In fact, Hood himself finds a bit of a problem in trying to find a cohesive, senseless juggle between the two demographics: For the kiddies out there, we have a few scenes of other kids playing video-games, goofing around with one another and getting into tiny scuffles; as for the parents, we have all sorts of war-fare, mixed with thought-provoking ideas about the humanity kept in one’s mind during war, the act of genocide itself and war crimes. So yeah, if you like your teen, sci-fi-thriller to be mixed with plenty of social-commentary, this is definitely the film for you.
However, it doesn’t quite work out that way, all due to the fact that we never know what this movie is working-up to, nor do we know what it’s trying to say. Most of the actual interesting stuff that does occur in this movie, probably happens in the first-hour when we see Ender go through this military school, where’s he’s made an example of, gets picked on and in some ways, picks fights with fellow students. It’s also interesting, if not tonally jarring, to see a movie that so clearly makes it a point to dehumanize these kids, just so that they can be “better soldiers”. A bit scary when you think about it happening to these small, innocent kids we see on-screen, but it’s even more frightening when we realize that it is actually happening out there in the real world that we live in. In some cases, maybe even right outside your door-step.
But like I was saying though, the movie makes it a point to always “be about something”, but at the same time, never seems like it’s really going anywhere with its countless bits of action or scenes where we see a bunch of kids yelling out random codes/jargon/exposition, in order for it all to make a lick of a difference. We know that whatever threat these kids are battling, is something that may be deadly and strike them at any moment, but instead of actually seeing these kids go to war and get their hands a bit dirty, we’re just watching them go through simulations. Sure, the simulations, as well as everything else in this movie, look mighty pretty and definitely have you feel like you’re right there in the moment, but they’re just simulations. Meaning, they aren’t the real-deal, so why in the heck do we have to have a film that builds up to that, and only that?
And then, the strangest part of this movie comes through when we get a “shocker” of an ending in which we see that the government itself is up to some sheisty-dealings. Won’t give too much away as to the “how’s” and the “why’s”, but I will say that it didn’t surprise me much here. Also, the notes that the movie ends on are some pretty interesting ones that you wouldn’t quite see in something that’s as slightly aimed towards kids as this is (ideas about sacrificing thousands of fellow soldiers for the almighty “win”, risking anything and everything, etc.), but then it also seems to just straggle those ideas out, in a way to make us realize the actual tension this story is supposed to be creating. It never materials to much, other than just a bunch of smart ideas, that probably would have been better, used in a far less-messy movie. Not to say that it’s all pretty crappy, but once things begin to get heavy, then the weight of the actual story itself begins to crush all of the fun and life that’s trying to get-out.
Perhaps though, the most interesting aspect surrounding this movie is the handling of its lead character, Ender, a character whom, from what I’ve heard, isn’t the most likable protagonist in the world. I can definitely see that too, because while the kid definitely seems like his heart may be in the right place with certain decisions made here and there, somehow, there’s this under-lining sense of sociopathic behavior to be found and that comes out quite a few times in this movie. It’s not fully fleshed-out to where it provides a huge inner-issue for Ender, but is seen on occasion and makes you think that maybe he’s a bit of a nut-job that not only shouldn’t be the head of the military-force, but also shouldn’t be allowed to walk the same streets as regular-day citizens like you or I.
That’s why it seems like this character would be terribly unlikable, but he actually isn’t. Which, in a sense, is more of a credit to Asa Butterfield’s acting, rather than the way the movie portrays him, because while the kid definitely seems to be a bit of stuck-up arse that needs to always get things right, he’s not necessarily a “bad” kid, that does bad things, for bad reasons; he’s just a kid who has been thrown into a situation that he wasn’t expecting, but is more than willing to give a try. Butterfield is good here and shows that he could definitely grow-up into some real, leading-man potential in the next couple of years, but it’s mainly the character of Ender that keeps us watching this kid, all because we don’t know who he’s going to humiliate next, or who he’s going to mouth-off to either.
Like Butterfield, everybody else is good, too, it’s just that they are given some pretty shaky dialogue to work with that I don’t even Daniel Day himself would be able to handle (that’s a joke, of course he would, he’s Daniel freakin’ Day-Lewis for gosh sakes!). Harrison Ford tries, but can’t help but give a one-note performance as the Colonel who believes in Ender so much, that he’s able to growl for him whenever necessary; Viola Davis shows up for a few scenes to show that she has “humanity” because she doesn’t want these kids tested, but is basically told to “take that crap elsewhere”; Hailee Steinfeld shows that she has potential as a leading-lady in the future, but is given a lot of jargon to say and none of it really makes sense, so it would be kind of hard to decide whether or not she’s good here, based solely on that; and Ben Kingsley shows up with a whole bunch of face-tattoos that make Mike Tyson look like a wuss, and doesn’t do much here either. Nice to see him and Ford share the same screen though, even if all they do is deliver exposition when they’re around one another. A damn shame passing up an opportunity like that when you have two great talents in the same room. A damn shame.
Consensus: There may be a very strange demographic that this movie is for, but Ender’s Game can’t quite figure who or what that is, so instead, gives us all the special-effects, action, sci-fi elements and social-messages it can possibly handle, but doesn’t do much to really build towards anything that could be deemed “exciting”.
6 / 10 = Rental!!
Photo’s Credit to: IMDB, Collider, Joblo, ComingSoon.net
Great review mate 🙂 I thought the same. It was a great movie but it was kind of jumbled and didn’t know who it was catering for.
It clearly had no idea as to who it was for, and therefore, was a bit of a jumble.
Honestly, I felt that way reading the book so I don’t think it’s necessarily the movie creators’ fault. The book is supposedly angled toward a young audience, but the material is heavy. I didn’t get around to reading the series until a few years ago, but when I did I was questioning the whole time how this was a “young adult novel”. Overall, I enjoyed the movie, but I agree there were some problems with it. I wrote a review when it first came out, mainly discussing why people should watch/read Ender’s Game despite Orson Scott Card being a jerk. Check it out if you want. Great review, by the way!
Yep, good credo: “love the art, not the artist.” And agree on the reading. Wrote up a long post on the adaptation (spoiler heavy, by necessity) http://literaryends.com/hgblog/adaptations-enders-game/ The book is a strange problem of intended audience versus who really found it. The next two in the series were decidedly more adult, however. I guess even he realized it was too much for young teens.
Hooray for the children! Or is it boo? I don’t know. I’ve heard a lot of mixed feelings about this flick. I’ll give a look at some point. Fine review.
Yes, please do as it definitely is an odd movie that deserves plenty of eyes on it.
Nice take 🙂 Sounds okay for me. Hasn’t released here. I guess we have seen worse & should give it a chance 🙂
Might as well since it isn’t all that bad.
Good review as always. You tend to watch a lot of films before I get the chance too, so I am going to point that once your post is something I watched as well, I can guarantee a better comment. Anyways, this was a maybe for me, but now it is even less of a chance that I’ll watch it. So, still benefited me by reading it!
If you’ve read the book, you may actually like this one so there’s hope in that.
Wasn’t a fan of this one at all. I thought the pacing was terrible, took ages to get going and then completely rushed the ending. Also, the fact that the world is being saved by a bunch of kids was just silly. Nice review though Dan.
It was silly, but it could have definitely been taken seriously. However, such was not the case here.
Can’t say this leaves me particularly excited. I’m sure I’ll give it a go at some point though!
Nice review as always!
Thanks to both of you!
Nice review Dan. Your comments epitomises why I ‘m not too keen in watching this film. Just looks like it’s not sure what it’s doing.
It doesn’t have a clue what it’s trying to do, but at least it’s an interesting mess.
Don’t understand how you can have a film in which Sir Ben Kingsley and Viola Davis are both underused. Good review sir.
That’s a bunch of bull, I say! Thanks man!
Good review, Dan! Quite agreed. It has the parts to be better, but it doesn’t capitalize on them. And winds up being no better than average.
Nice read. Avoided this one as I thought the trailer looked pretty bad. Might catch it eventually… when it’s on TV.
Great review, man! I think I enjoyed it a little bit more than you, but I definitely agree with your review. It’s flawed to be sure, but I appreciated the fact that it tried to do something unique.
I watched this myself last night, my review will be up asap and I agree with your rating here. Not a bad movie. Nice review
Great review. By the way you’ve won a screenkicker award!
Nice post Dan. Not had any particular desire to see this and your great review seems to confirm that.
Nice review dude. I liked the book, but was skeptical on the movie. I guess I might skip it. Your caption on Ben Kingsley’s picture was quite funny by the way!
When I saw the trailer for this – as well as a few promotional clips – I thought it looked very average. It turns out my suspicions were merited. Thanks for the warning Dan!
Glad to see I’m not the only one who thought the demographic they shot for with this movie was a mistake… as a huge fan of the novel, I thought the decision to shoot for the young adult “Hunger Games” crowd a terrible mistake tone wise for the film.
Nice review, man. I was pretty excited for this but thought it was a bit of a let down. Just seemed to be floating around in the cinematic ether. Not sure what it was going for but it does look pretty nice.
Still sounds fun. I’ll check it out at some point. Nice review. : )
Cool review. I’m still a bit curious about this one. I read the book like a gazillion years ago. Good review, like always, Dan. Thanks!
[…] “There may be a very strange demographic that this movie is for, but Ender’s Game can’t quite figure who or what that is, so instead, gives us all the special-effects, action, sci-fi elements and social-messages it can possibly handle, but doesn’t do much to really build towards anything that could be deemed “exciting”.” Dan the Man’s Movie Reviews. Full Review […]
Had a lot of the same reactions, though for, often different reasons. Most folks forget this was originally written for teens, not adults. It took on a life of its own (much like Hunger Games) and transcended the age group. But really, for me, the fault in the movie was not dividing it into two. It was too big a story to tell in one go, and cheated all the subtle factors around Ender (especially his sibs and the mind game) and the rest of the kids in battle school. Talk about squandering a potential franchise; if they’d had the guts to invest and gamble, it might have been much better. As it is, yeah, good moments, pretty pictures, and inklings of potential. I expect it will get remade in a few years as a mini-series or a reboot to (hopefully) get it right.
It wasn’t at all what I expected when I saw it. Great review 😀 I’m a fan 😀
Loved the review. I hear so many good things so I am not completely sure about it… hmmmm…
I thought the final point the movie made after the battle is when it became interesting and it is a shame it ended. Before that, apart from the cool special effects I thought the movie simply did not have enough depth to the characters. Ender always seems to be right and has an answer for everything and because of that the conflicts with other characters never seem to be true conflicts. He ends up doing it his way no matter what.
Pretty much summed up my thoughts on this one too, Dan. The film just went nowhere, and it’s downer ending came as too melancholy for the rest of what could have been a fairly sprightly sci-fi actioner. Bloodless, mindless action does not a great film make.
Nice review Dan. I share your opinion on the target audience for this movie.
On a different level, and after the long build towards the climactic simulation/battle at the end of the movie, everything is wrapped up abruptly with many questions left unanswered. Does this mean there will be sequels?
Great review Dan. As someone who loved the book growing up, I was skeptical about how they could adapt it into a decent film. And Gavin Hood actually surprised me by doing it pretty well. He manages to execute a high concept adaptation while keeping most of the story intact. Unfortunately he does have to cut from a few key places, but I generally found this movie engaging. I think the film’s greatest weaknesses are its performances, which for the most part are pretty lame and its ending, which was pretty stupid. Thought Ford and Kingsley were okay, however Butterfield has zero charisma to me. I couldn’t stand how Hood tweaked the book’s ending. Overall, I didn’t expect to like Ender’s Game and I did.